Stage 2: The Contemplation
AX.C.16.04.04.02
Purpose: Slow the pace. Give players time to think, plan, and roleplay. Build tension through anticipation rather than action.
Structure:
- Significantly different challenge type from Stage 1
- Rewards careful thought over quick action
- Reveals information or forces choice
Challenge Types:
- Riddle: Traditional puzzle with cryptic clues
- Moral Choice: No clearly right answer; consequences either way
- NPC Interaction: Bargaining, gathering information, persuasion
- Investigation: Searching for clues, piecing together a mystery
- Trap Complexity: Multi-step puzzle trap requiring coordination
- Resource Decision: Which path? What to bring? Who goes first?
Plot Integration: Reveal deeper motivations or complications in the primary plot. This is where players learn what's really at stake.
Examples by Plot Type:
- Revenge (3-1): Meet an NPC who reveals the "criminal" may not be guilty; must choose whether to continue
- Disaster (1-2): Find the messenger's final words; learn the vanquished power had good reasons
- Ambition (6-5): Discover the ambitious person's tragic backstory; is the coveted object worth the cost?
Design Tips:
- No combat in Stage 2 unless the entire stage is a tense negotiation
- Multiple NPCs provide richer interaction; see AX.C.16.03 for quick NPC construction
- Prepare 2–3 possible solutions
- Information gathered here should be useful in Stages 3–4
- Give quiet characters spotlight moments
- This should take 30–45 minutes of game time
Sample Moral Choices:
- "The artifact can save one village but doom another which one?"
- "The prisoner knows the way forward but wants freedom; do you release them?"
- "The ritual requires a sacrifice; who gives what up?"