Reading Results
AX.C.16.02.03
Clean success (met threshold): The action succeeds as declared. Narrate what happened and move the scene forward. The size of the pool doesn't change the quality of the outcome, meeting the threshold is meeting the threshold.
Excess successes (exceeded threshold by 1 or more): The character succeeded with margin. This is the GM's invitation to add something, a piece of additional information, a positional advantage, a detail that carries forward into the next scene. Excess successes aren't a separate mechanical system; they are narrative latitude the GM can use or leave alone.
Narrow failure (1 success short): The character came close. This is where success with cost is most appropriate, the GM may offer the character what they were attempting, but something is spent, damaged, or compromised alongside it. The lock opened, but the pick broke inside. The NPC agreed, but overheard the wrong thing on the way out. Not every narrow failure warrants this treatment, but it is always available as an option.
Clear failure (2 or more short): The action failed and it was apparent. Narrate the failure directly, don't soften a clear failure into a near-miss. But the scene should still move. What did the character observe in failing? What condition changed? A failed roll that produces nothing, no new information, no shifted circumstance, no consequence, was a wasted roll. Something should be different after the dice land than before.
The forward principle: A scene should be in a different state after a roll than it was before, regardless of result. Success moves the fiction in the direction the character intended. Failure moves it somewhere else. Both are valid; stasis is not.