Skip to content
When to Call for a Roll

When to Call for a Roll

AX.C.16.02.01

The criteria for calling a roll: the outcome is uncertain AND both success and failure produce something worth playing. If either condition isn't met, don't roll.

Three categories that don't need dice:

Trivial actions, A trained character doing something well within their capability against no meaningful resistance. A skilled climber ascending a ladder. A soldier drawing their weapon. A scholar recalling a fact from their own specialty. Calling for a roll here communicates that the task is harder than it looks, which is either wrong, or a lie the GM will have to sustain.

Impossible actions, No pool size will produce the needed outcome. A character cannot pick a lock they have no picks for, or convince an NPC established as incorruptible to accept a bribe. Rolling and failing communicates the same thing as declaring it impossible, but wastes time and sets a misleading precedent that dice could have helped.

Inconsequential actions, The outcome doesn't change anything about the scene. Whether the character succeeds or fails at identifying the paint color on a wall, the scene continues identically. If neither outcome matters, the roll doesn't matter.

The over-rolling problem: Every roll carries an implicit stake, the table is paying attention because something might go wrong. Frequent calls for inconsequential rolls train players to look for risk where none exists, and to feel cheated when rolls produce nothing. Reserve dice for moments that deserve them.

© 2026 AxiomRPG - One engine, Any world. All rights reserved.